Second Place is the First Loser: The World According to Sports

I’m in the middle of reading the current issue of Christianity Today and I have to admit that I am stunned. I have been reading CT for years and it is usually pretty careful not to be prophetic. But this issue’s cover story is different. It is titled “Fanatics: How Christians Have Succumbed to the Culture of Sports” and it is a pretty sharp rebuke of how important sports have become to those in the church and how little we have thought about them from a theological point of view. I mean, what is the purpose of sports in God’s world? Is competition beneficial or detrimental to our Christian maturity? Is it more important in our minds if our kids win hockey tournaments or follow Jesus? Have we ever even asked these questions of ourselves? I’m an avid fan of a number of (really bad) teams and I grew up playing all kinds of competitive sports, but I don’t ever recall thinking too deeply about how my Christian faith ought to interact with my participation in or support of a particular team.
As part of his argument, the author of the article, Shirl James Hoffman, gives a number of examples of Christians behaving badly in the sporting world. Here is an interesting paragraph:
A Christian high school in Tennessee that prides itself on a bold evangelical stance and fields a powerhouse football team became national front-page fodder for its questionable ethics; two nationally known evangelical coaches were criticized by the press for refusing to concede that their football teams won only because referees had admittedly made mistakes near the end of the game; the basketball program at a large Christian university became so disjointed from its mission (“advancing the frontiers of knowledge while cultivating a Christian worldview”) that it became a poster child for just how slimy the subculture of university athletics can get; and the creation of the Christian Wrestling Federation, Christian Wrestling Entertainment, and Ultimate Christian Wrestling – all of which promise spectators the same violence, celebration of power, and grotesque images and freak-show ambiance seen on TV, but not, its promoters point out, “cursing or women parading in skimpy costumes.” All of these suggest it is time for evangelicals to step back and rethink their liaison with big-time sports.
The last example he cites regarding the Christian wrestlers is particularly troubling to me. The only thing that makes these matches Christian is the absence of cursing and skin. Really? Is it really the case that the sum total of “worldliness”, as the Scriptures use the term, is found in sexuality and swearing? Something is wrong here. Are we really that shallow in our assessment of these kinds of things?
I suppose my question is pretty simple – Why have we never asked questions about the nature of sports and the influence they have on our Christian lives? Isn’t it time we thought about it a bit?
#1 from david on February 16, 2010
“Why have we never asked questions about the nature of sports and the influence they have on our Christian lives? Isn’t it time we thought about it a bit?”
To answer your first question , i dont think it is suprising that many (ps i burnt my clutch out 2 years ago doing smokeshows when canucks moved into the second round) do not question the nature of sports in relation to god… when you consider the breadth of thing that are not questioned. But for me i know why i dont like to question it… because i love it. It is important to me , it entertains me , it makes me feel good. But for the bad that i so often (maybe even always…)neglect.
NOt sports in particular but the competitive nature which sports generally tend to induce(or more accurately draw out) , has been highly detrimental to me. I like everything from ufc to hockey to football (the nfl ... not the cfl..i said football not figure skating). But it enflares a sense of competitiveness in me which draws out my inherent carnality… i often times find myself gleefull when an opposing player gets injured on the field… without second thought to his well being nor what effect it will have on his family. It draws out this kill or be killed mentality…. this desire to succeed by crushing the opponents…. this base carnality. Evident when i am on a bus. No word of a lie , i will be on a bus ... and ill look around at all the the guys on it and think to myself “I could beat the crap outta everyone on this bus. Even that guy over there whos got 90lbs on me…. look at him… probably never been in a fight…. one elbow to the jaw and…. wait… am i seriously thinking about elbowing this guy in the face?”.... no word of a lie that stuff goes through my head sometimes…. no its not because of sports…. but that carnality is what sports draws outta me…. fair to say though because that is what is in me. I dont personally believe this obsession with sports stems from a christian worldview…... our sports are a few leagues removed from being the roman colisseum. Thank goodness for feigned empathy…...